A Syriac Chrestomathy

sources for syriacists

R3 · nestle-1889-en/r3/c105-1

work vitae-prophetarum:elisha+job

work_note

The page opens inside the Life of ELISHA, whose one-word rubric ܐܠܝܫܥ ܂ stands on p. 104 line 12 (= piece line 369). One Life boundary falls here, marked by the usual cue — a one-word name rubric alone on its own line, closed by a low point: · line 8 of the page (= piece line 385) ܐܝܘܒ ܂ — JOB.

⭐ AND THAT IS A REAL FINDING, not a slip of the eye. The word was read at ~11x on four clean, unambiguous glyphs — alaph "≺" · yudh (tiny blob) · waw (closed loop with a leg) · beth (flat-topped hook with a leftward foot) — and there is no competing candidate at that shape. JOB IS NOT IN Schermann's Latin capitulum of Sinai Syr. 10 at all, whose 22 run Moyses … Ioel, with Malachias appended. So Nestle's British-Museum recension carries a Life the Sinai witness does not, and the control is silent on the whole of this page's second half. Job does stand in some Greek/Syriac recensions of the Lives, so this is a recension difference to be recorded, not an anomaly to be explained away — but it should be checked by a Syriacist against Schermann's GREEK recensions A-E (pp. 1-104) before it is asserted in print.

Nestle names no individual codex; "e tribus codicibus Musei Britannici" (p. 86) is all he says, and he never says which of the three. No witness field exists in the schema — known gap.

layer unvocalized Estrangela, with seyame and the diacritic points
layer_source read from the plate

layer_note

Verified on this page: no vowel signs on any of the 20 lines; seyame on plurals; dalath/rish points present. Constant with pp. 103, 104, 106, 107 and with p. 86.

diff_target

Th. Schermann, PROPHETARUM VITAE FABULOSAE, Teubner 1907 — archive.org prophetarumvita00schegoog. Latin version of the Syriac (cod. Sinait. syro 10) at pp. 105-106, leaf = page + 74 (calibrated on two running heads); Index nominum propriorum at printed p. 240. ⛔ The Latin Appendix is a two-page CAPITULUM (a summary list of 22 prophets with tribe, date and burial place), not the full Lives — SENSE-level control only, and a thin one. It catches a mis-keyed name or a meaningless sentence; it never adjudicates pointing and cannot be aligned page-for-page. See research/syriac-peshitta-editions.md

seyame yes
lines_per_page 20

line_numbers

380, 385, 390, 395 — read off the plate in the RIGHT (outer) margin of this recto, standing against printed lines 3, 8, 13 and 18. The page therefore carries piece lines 378-397. Numbering CONTINUOUS; 385 sits against the ܐܝܘܒ rubric line itself and the count runs straight through the boundary.

page_number_form Syriac numeral letter, centred at head, above the first text band
page_number_read ܩܗ = 100 + 5 = 105 — qoph (loop + bar) + he (the double-arch ന). Agrees with leaf = page + 89.

transcription_note

Same conventions as c103-1: seyame → U+0308, linea occultans → U+0304, low point → ܂, two-dot pause → ܆, end mark → ܀. Qushshaya/rukkakha and participle points are on the plate and are NOT transcribed — a known gap, not a claim of absence. No square brackets occur on this page. Doubtful words → ⟨?…⟩; an unread line is emitted in position as ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩. Nothing was filled in from the Latin or Greek control.

text_syr_voc

⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ܐܝܘܒ ܂ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩ ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩

primer_notes

NONE on this page. No rule and no smaller type at the foot; the twentieth text line runs to the bottom of the type area.

extraction

status

keyed from the plate, PARTIAL and UNVERIFIED: 1 of 20 printed lines carries a reading (the Job rubric); 19 are emitted as ⟨?LINE NOT READ⟩

reason

Same measured ceiling as c103-1 — see that record's [extraction] for the numbers, the two calibration aids (Nestle's alphabet table at leaf n21; the labelled specimen at p. 86 lines 1-3) and the confirmation that the archive.org item carries NO OCR (_djvu.txt is 0 bytes). The one-word rubrics come out because an isolated short word can be attacked glyph by glyph at 11x; running narrative cannot, at ~5-6 zoom crops per line with silent residual error.

alignment

status

structure and the one rubric keyed from Nestle; checked against Schermann 1907 (Latin capitulum of Sinai Syr. 10) — and the check came back NEGATIVE, see diff

diff

⭐ THE CONTROL'S MOST USEFUL RESULT ON THIS PAGE IS A MISMATCH. The Latin capitulum of Sinai Syr. 10 lists 22 prophets and JOB IS NOT AMONG THEM. So the rubric read at line 385 either (a) records a Life present in the BM recension and absent from the Sinai one, or (b) is a mis-reading. (b) is unlikely — ܐܝܘܒ is four unambiguous glyphs at 11x with no near neighbour in the Estrangela repertoire — but the two possibilities are named rather than collapsed, and the resolution is a Syriacist's look at Schermann's GREEK recensions A-E (pp. 1-104, leaves ~75- 178; RE-CALIBRATE the leaf offset from a running head first, the item's _page_numbers.json is wrong in this volume). WHAT THE CONTROL DID CONFIRM: X. Elisaeus fuit ex tribu Ruben, eratque discipulus Eliae. — Elisha, whose Life occupies lines 378-384 of this page, is in the Sinai list. WHAT IT CANNOT DO: it is a summary list in Latin against continuous Syriac narrative; not one line of running text on this page has a parallel in it, and it never adjudicates a letter, a point or a seyame.

UNCERTAIN READINGS ON THIS PAGE: · lines 1-7 and 9-20 — not read at all. · ܐܝܘܒ is recorded as a confident reading of the LETTERS. Its IDENTIFICATION as a Life of Job in this recension is flagged above as needing the Greek control, which is a different claim.

source

primer nestle-1889-en
page 105
leaf n194